Saturday, November 08, 2014

Trojan Postmortem

Last night was the first Friday of November, bringing with it a full moon and the opening of the high school football playoffs in Ohio. As a member of Division II, had Troy made the playoffs, they would have played last night, and I would have been there. Alas, they did not, and so instead I watched one of their opponents from this season (Cincinnati Northwest) play on television. For what it's worth, they lost to Kings.

The years pass and football seasons come and go, but one thing that never changes from year to year is how the end of the season always sneaks up on me. During the non-football portion of the year, it's what I look forward to, what I'm thinking about in my quiet moments, and that time seems to pass so slowly. Then August rolls around, the first game kicks off, and the next thing you know it's November and it's done, and back into waiting mode for me.

In past years, I know I've promised season recaps and then failed to deliver them. In 2012 and 2013, finishing both seasons with losses to Piqua and ending with disappointing records, I've been a little too disheartened to actually look back, despite the best of intentions. Not that this year was any less disheartening--just look at that 1-9 record, and unfortunately, the "1" wasn't the season finale with Piqua--but this year I have some things I definitely need to say.

It's time for some real talk: I have no idea what has happened to Troy football.

I think back to the late '90s, the teams that were led by Ryan Brewer, by far the best high school football player I've ever seen or expect to see, and that were just loaded with talent all over the field. Then I go back earlier than that, to when I was in high school, starting with the '91 season. Troy only made the playoffs once during my high school days, in 1992, but even then, those teams were never anything less than solid. When the OHSAA announced its plans to expand the playoffs to include eight teams per region instead of four, I remember thinking that Troy would rarely if ever miss the playoffs again. That expansion happened in 1999, the first post-Brewer season for Troy (had it happened a year sooner, the Trojans, at 8-2 and #7 in their region, would have made the playoffs in all four of Brewer's seasons); in the sixteen seasons since, the Trojans have actually qualified for the playoffs just four times.

So. Obviously I was wrong about how the Trojans would fare under the expanded system. It seems to me that the talent available to the Trojans football team has thinned considerably since those heady days of state rankings and relatively frequent playoff berths, and I am at a complete loss to explain why. I've been out of Troy for much of that time, but I don't feel like the demographics of the town have changed so much. I've heard some people point to the establishment of Troy Christian High School as a possible explanation; while it may have some very small effect, it can't be the sole factor--it's a small school, Troy is not the only community they draw students from, and they only have twenty players on their team.

One thing I do wonder about: it seems that football has been (at least somewhat) de-emphasized in the grand athletic hierarchy at Troy High School. There used to be a "Touchdown Club," a booster group dedicated solely to the football team; I'm pretty sure that no longer exists, and has been rolled into the all-sports booster group. If that's the case, I have to wonder in what other ways focus has shifted away from football, and what kind of effect that can have on the program. I have no idea - just blue-skying it here.

I also have to wonder about the offense. In the last few years of his tenure, longtime head coach Steve Nolan (now the head coach at Troy Christian) was adding some more modern elements to his traditional ground-and-pound Wing-T offense, but it remained a conservative, run-heavy offense. When Scot Brewer came aboard as head coach in 2012, he scrapped the Wing-T entirely, but has stuck with the run-first philosophy. In an era of uptempo spread offenses that like to air it out, I have to wonder if this philosophy is one that kids don't want to play in. Again, I doubt this is much of a factor, but is it one at all? Honestly, no clue.

Whatever the case, something has to be done about the offense, which was, not to put too fine a point on it, pretty dreadful this year. That's what I would point to as the main cause for Troy's final 1-9 record this season. The defense was pretty stellar, all things considered, but the lack of offense was just too much for them to overcome. The Trojans only topped 300 yards of total offense once all year, with 388 in, not surprisingly, their 27-0 win over Sidney. Five times they failed to gain 200 yards, and twice they didn't even make it to 100.

I mentioned that Coach Brewer went away from the Wing-T when he took over, and indeed, this year Troy ran almost entirely out of a spread formation with the quarterback lining up in a pistol/shotgun. Despite that, 66% of Troy's offensive plays (344/519) were run plays. Now, my football fandom was established watching Coach Nolan's Wing-T, and I love a run-heavy offense...but if you're going to run a spread, I do feel like there needs to be more balance. The spread can be great for a running offense, but only if the defense believes they have to spread out to defend the pass. It was pretty obvious that defenses this year were loading up to stop Troy's run game, knowing they were going to rely on it, and willing to take their chances with the pass. Unfortunately, the Trojans didn't/couldn't make them pay for that. I'll note here that on their 344 rushing attempts on the year, Troy gained 3.31 yards per carry; on their 175 passing plays, they gained 4.87 yards per attempts, and 11.37 yards per completion. Now, the 43% completion rate (75/175) wasn't ideal, obviously, but still, a few more passes would, I think, have been a good idea.

It's also worth mentioning that the rushing offense was pretty apparently at its best when Elijah Pearson was getting the bulk of the carries. He had 52 rushing attempts in the first three games, and then I think he had some injury issues, and only carried the ball 34 times the rest of the season, including none against Wayne and just one each against Trotwood and Piqua. He finished the year with 445 yards on 36 carries, a respectable 5.2 per. No disrespect to Brandon Lee, a good, hard runner and fun to watch, but Elijah brought a different wrinkle to the offense that they just couldn't replicate with anyone else. Fortunately, he'll be back for the Trojans next year, and with Josh Browder joining him in the backfield and Hayden Kotwica back at quarterback, the Trojans will at least have some offensive weapons to work with.

Friday, October 31, 2014

Piqua 41 Troy 10

Let's get this part out of the way up front: my nephew Dylan was Piqua's starting center, and this was his senior night. That makes things a little uncomfortable for me. I wanted him to do well, of course, but no amount of nephews on the roster could actually make me want the team to win (against anyone, really, but especially against Troy).

Anyway, because it was Dylan's senior night, my dad came to the game with me, the first time we've been to a football game together in 22 years--another Troy-Piqua game, in fact: the 1992 playoff game at Welcome Stadium. I was a high school sophomore, and Dad took me and my friends Patrick and Jason down to the game. Superstitious folks might suggest I should reconsider asking him to future games, as both times resulted in Troy losses.

The night was cold, wet, windy, and mostly miserable. Sometimes that can be an equalizer, but that requires one team to be less affected by the conditions than the other. On this night, that was not the case. Piqua was, as their final 5-5 record would indicate, a perfectly average football team, but that still put them well ahead of the Trojans. (And yes, it hurt to type that.) Troy's defense held them in check fairly well for a long time, keeping the game close for probably longer than it should have been; it was only 14-3 at halftime. But with the offense unable to muster anything, the defense just wore out, resulting in long touchdown runs for each of Piqua's two backs and the lopsided final score (which included, yes, one more dose of the dreaded running clock--only for the final 2:38, but still).

Losing to Piqua sucks. Losing three in a row to Piqua sucks. Losing to Piqua to end the season sucks. Finishing the season 1-9 sucks; but, at the same time, the season being over also sucks. Plenty of suck to go around. Now the long wait begins for next season, exactly 43 weeks from now. Look for a season wrap within a few days.

Friday, October 24, 2014

Butler 38 Troy 7

What a difference a week makes.

As "on" as the Trojans looked last week in their first win of the season over Sidney, that's how "off" they looked tonight against the Butler Aviators. Missed tackles, dropped passes, turnovers, name it. They played hard, and at times they even played well, but they just couldn't put anything together. The defense couldn't get off the field when it needed to, and the offense couldn't get much going. The Trojans' lone score of the night came when a muffed punt by Vandalia gave them the ball in the red zone.

So. The less said about this one, the better. Now it's Piqua week, as the Trojans (1-8) and their northern counterparts (4-5) get set to meet for the 130th time, with Troy looking for their first victory in the series since 2010. No conference titles are on the line, no playoff spots, nothing but pride. A win in this one would be a sweet way for the Troy seniors to end their careers, and the rest of the boys to go into the offseason.

Friday, October 17, 2014

Troy 27 Sidney 0

Not everyone understands why I spend my Fridays in the fall chasing the Troy Trojans up and down the I-75 corridor or wherever else in Ohio the schedule may take them. That was true even when I lived in Troy and most games were just across town or a short drive away; it's more true now that we live in the state capital and every game I attend involves a long and often-maddening slog across I-70 and back into the Miami Valley.

I love the action on the field, of course, but that's only part of the story. More than that, when I watch sports--and this goes for any sport, not just Troy football--I'm interested in the story, the human moments that go along with the game, the season, the moment. The best illustration I can think of for this happened several years ago when I was flipping channels and stopped for a moment on an NCAA women's basketball tournament game between Ohio State and Duke. The game was nearly over, and an Ohio State player was shooting free throws to ice the victory; as she got set, the camera flashed to Duke player Georgia Schweitzer, a senior in her final game that was about to end. She had tears streaming down her she settled into her stance and got ready to play on despite them. That's always stuck with me, and that was in a game I didn't care about between two teams I didn't care about.

All of which brings us back to this year's Troy Trojans, 0-7 coming into this game and, all things considered, no particular incentive to do anything other than mail in the rest of the season. Well, no incentive beyond pride, of course--and, as it turns out, that's something these Trojans have in spades. Sure, one way or another this is going to end up as a losing season, atypical in the rich history of Troy football, but this year's crop of Trojans has played all year with a visible determination to give their opponents everything they have. On this night, that determination paid off.

These Trojans have played their asses off all year and, as I said, came into this game with an 0-7 record to show for it, due largely to a brutal schedule. So while, on an intellectual level, I couldn't agree with senior receiver Billy Smith doing a flip into the endzone after sprinting 85 yards for the Trojans' third touchdown early in the fourth quarter, earning a flag for unsportsmanlike conduct in the process, in practice I couldn't do anything but smile. The kid had pretty much just sealed his team's first win of the season. He wants to show a little joy? I can get behind that.

The Trojans just looked so solid tonight all the way around. The defense...what can I say about them? Lights out. Time after time they had to come up big to keep Sidney off the board, and time after time they did it. Even when the win was well in hand, they kept up their intensity, wanting to ensure not just the win, but the shutout. Seeing the kids celebrate and congratulate each other on the sideline as the clock wound down was another "Georgia Schweitzer moment" that will stick with me for a long time.

Friday, September 12, 2014

Miamisburg 45 Troy 14

Unfortunately, I have to begin again by decrying the new OHSAA mercy rule that mandates a running clock in the second half of a game in the case of a 30+ point deficit. The Vikings were up 38-0 at halftime, and the entire second half was played under the rule. Again, it's just too aggressive--if nothing else, they should stop the clock for penalties. A couple of times there were flags thrown and a ton of time came off the clock while the officials talked to each other, talked to players, talked to coaches, announced the penalties, marked it off, and readied the ball for play. Too much time. Each time got two possessions in the second half, and that was it. The Trojans scored touchdowns on both of theirs. Not saying they would have been able to get back into the game; just saying they didn't even get a chance to bring the score under the 30-point mark to get the game back to normal.

At any rate, there isn't much to say about this one. Miamisburg was just bigger, faster, better than Troy. Again, the Trojans played hard from start to finish, and there's talent here and there, but not enough to compete. At least not yet--most of these players are young, and gaining valuable experience.

On the bright side, it was a beautiful, picture-perfect night for football. I wore a long-sleeved t-shirt to the game and put on a sweatshirt as the sun went down. Not bad for what's technically still summer--normally nights like this don't happen until October.

Saturday, September 06, 2014

A Quick Note on Being a Better Sports Fan

Are you a sports fan? Well, hold on to your hat, because I'm about to give you some groundbreaking, never-before-heard advice on how to be a better sports fan. I daresay that following this advice will make you the best sports fan you can be, not to mention a better human being. Ready? Here goes.

Don't tell other people how to be fans.

That's it. That's the list.

Certainly in the months and years you've spent being a fan of a certain team, you have absolutely perfected it. You. You are the pinnacle of fandom. Compared to you, everyone else in the stadium--nay, the world--is sucky.


You may find this hard to believe, but other fans don't fan the way you fan. As inconceivable as it may be, that does not mean that these other fans are doing it wrong. Your insistence that it is otherwise is not welcome. If you persist, you risk going from "annoyance" to "asshole."

Here's what happened.

Brandi and I returned to our beloved alma mater, Bowling Green State University, for the football team's hope opener against VMI. The BGSU Falcons ended up winning the game 48-7, so clearly the VMI Keydets were overmatched. Now, in the early stages of the game, there was plenty of cheering whenever the Falcons did something good, which was often. As the game went on and the outcome was less and less in doubt, the cheering cooled off. The crowd thinned out and quieted down. This was not to the liking of one dude in the front of our section, who repeatedly waved his arms at those of us behind him in an effort to get us to stand up and make more noise.

Before I go any further, let me say that, in what I've said so far, I've been this guy before. I've been in crowds that I wished were louder and more enthusiastic, and I've done the arm wave thing. I will say that I only remember doing it a handful of times, for really close, really big games. However: I get it. You feel like the crowd should be up,  you feel like you can influence them in that direction, you start flapping your arms. Cool.

So needless to say, I didn't hate the guy's message, although I did think it was a little unnecessary as the third quarter was winding down and the Falcons were up by 34 points. The game was over. Still, if that was as far as it had gone, it would have been fine. That was not as far as it went, though. After a certain length of time had passed in non-loudness and numerous arm-waves had gone unheeded, dude's cup runneth over and he started berating those of us lucky enough to be in the superfan section for not supporting the team, not caring, not being fans. Because of course he did. Brandi and I had noted previously that we were sitting in front of one player's parents and another player's grandparents, but hell yeah, dude, these people don't care.

Anyway, after a certain amount of abuse tossed our way, a few words were lobbed back in dude's direction, which, surprisingly, did not defuse the situation. Dude doubled down on his argument, more words were exchanged, and, with the third quarter closing and the game well in hand, Brandi and I decided it was time to go.

And this is exactly my point. Along with violating Wheaton's Law, dude trying to increase support for the team ended up driving two fans from the stadium, thus defeating his own purpose. And I'm not an early leaver--I go to a lot of sporting events, and I can count on one hand the number of times I've left before the final gun, and that includes many blowouts (both wins and losses for my team), crazy weather, and what have you. And I'll note here that I'm not knocking people who leave early; I'm just saying that staying until the end is what I like to do. You want to scream your face off at what ended up being a 41-point blowout? I respect that. Actually, I think it's kind of awesome; it's just not my thing. Me, I'll be behind you, kicking back with a brewski, enjoying the sunshine and the fact that my team's got one in the bag. If that bothers you to the point where you actually have to be a jackass to complete strangers, it seems to me that you're the one with the problem.

EDITED TO ADD: On the bright side, it was an otherwise spectacular day. I'll be writing about the good part as time allows.

EDITED (AGAIN) TO ADD: Writing about the good part has now taken place and can be found here.

Friday, August 29, 2014

CJ 42 Troy 7

Let's get this out of the way first: the OHSAA made a rule change this year, under which a deficit of more than 30 points in the second half results in a running clock, to decrease the amount of time spent in an obvious mismatch. As this game had a 35-point halftime deficit, I got a chance to see the new rule in action from the get-go. I can see pros and cons of it, but after seeing for myself how it goes, I can say that I think it's a little too aggressive. From the time the ball is kicked off, the clock runs, except in the case of a timeout or (I assume) an injury. I'd like to see it dialed back just a bit, so that the clock would stop for incomplete passes or a ball carrier going out of bounds, until the ball is reset for play.

Of course, I would have preferred not to see the new rule come into play at all, or for Troy to be on the other end of the blowout, but that wasn't to be.

I will say that this Trojan team presents a contrast to last year's team. Last year the Trojans featured quite a bit of talent, but they just never quite seemed to get it all together and have their heads in the game. That aspect, even in game one, looked to be greatly improved. The talent, on the other hand, just isn't quite there, or isn't quite ready, at the very least. A lot of new names and faces were all over the field, and against a good, experienced team like CJ, that makes for a rough start. I do feel like the Trojans will come together and get better as the season goes on, but man, they've got a tough schedule.

I also have to say that the Trojans appear to have a horse at tailback. Elijah Pearson ran for 140 yards (behind an inexperienced offensive line) and looked good doing it. As usual at Troy, the running game will be fine. The rest of the offense showed some flashes, so we'll just have to see how it goes. I think the defense probably needs more work, as they got beat on some long pass plays and had some trouble tackling as well. Of course, Coach Brewer comes from the defensive side of the ball, which has always been a strength during his tenure (as d-coordinator and as head coach), so I'm confident that better days are on the horizon.

And as always, even though the outcome wasn't what I hoped for, it was good to be back at Troy Memorial Stadium to see the red and gray back in action. I will not be following the Trojans for their first road game at Cincinnati Northwest next week, as I'm going with my wife to her alma mater's game for a cheerleader alumni event, so I'll be reporting instead from Eastwood at Clyde.