Baseball really needs to figure out what to do with these steroid cases. Within a few years, we're going to be looking at a Hall of Fame which doesn't include the all-time home runs leader (Bonds), the single-season home runs leader (Bonds), or the top single-season home run totals of all time (Bonds, McGwire, Sosa, Maris), not to mention the all-time hits leader (Rose). To me, a Hall of Fame without those top players has no credibility at all. Until they figure out how to reconcile it, Hall of Fame honors are meaningless as far as I'm concerned. Given the fact that a whole era has the pall of steroids cast over it, and that baseball has historically been a bastion of cheating, I think the Hall of Fame voters need to overlook the steroids issue for the time being. Put the guys in based on their numbers and careers, and start over with a clean slate for players in the current era of at least limited testing. Anyone who gets caught doing it now that the testing procedures are in place, sure, they're up for debate when their careers are over. The guys who played when there was no testing...well, it's over and done with now. Leaving them out based on speculation or even based on something illegal that baseball itself wasn't concerned with at the time seems ludicrous to me.
Friday, January 12, 2007
Baseball's Hall of Fame is Dead to Me
Baseball really needs to figure out what to do with these steroid cases. Within a few years, we're going to be looking at a Hall of Fame which doesn't include the all-time home runs leader (Bonds), the single-season home runs leader (Bonds), or the top single-season home run totals of all time (Bonds, McGwire, Sosa, Maris), not to mention the all-time hits leader (Rose). To me, a Hall of Fame without those top players has no credibility at all. Until they figure out how to reconcile it, Hall of Fame honors are meaningless as far as I'm concerned. Given the fact that a whole era has the pall of steroids cast over it, and that baseball has historically been a bastion of cheating, I think the Hall of Fame voters need to overlook the steroids issue for the time being. Put the guys in based on their numbers and careers, and start over with a clean slate for players in the current era of at least limited testing. Anyone who gets caught doing it now that the testing procedures are in place, sure, they're up for debate when their careers are over. The guys who played when there was no testing...well, it's over and done with now. Leaving them out based on speculation or even based on something illegal that baseball itself wasn't concerned with at the time seems ludicrous to me.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment